Donor Retention Beyond GivingTuesday: Turning One Day of Giving into Lasting Support

In this episode of The ENGAGE Podcast, host M. Love-Tinker, MBA, is joined by fellow Blackbaud Advisory+ consultant Julie Gerg to discuss how nonprofits can turn GivingTuesday gifts into long-term donor relationships. They explore donor retention, post-campaign stewardship, donor segmentation, and recurring giving, with practical ways to keep first-time and seasonal donors engaged beyond year-end.

Pocket Operations is a series of practical tip episodes presented by Blackbaud Advisory+, a team of experts who help customers turn their potential into reality.

Listen Now:

Key talking points

  • GivingTuesday donor retention should focus on relationships: A GivingTuesday gift is the beginning of a donor journey, not the end of a campaign. 
  • The first 90 days need a donor stewardship plan: Map the next three touchpoints: a prompt acknowledgment of gratitude, a mission-impact communication, and a relevant engagement opportunity. 
  • Donor segmentation makes follow-up more relevant: Show how giving history, preferences, campaign coding, and engagement information can tailor communication instead of sending every donor through the same path.
  • Recurring giving needs a thoughtful invitation: Explore ways to introduce monthly giving as a path to continued support without making every post-campaign interaction feel like another solicitation.
  • Clear ownership keeps donor engagement on track: Assign an owner to each personal or automated follow-up, coordinate the communication cadence, and record interactions.
  • Sustainable improvement starts small: Choose a manageable donor retention process to test, measure, and improve rather than attempting a complete fundraising overhaul.

GivingTuesday and Donor Retention Resources: 

Transcript:

M Love-Tinker
So Julie, when GivingTuesday ends and the final results are tallied, what should nonprofit leaders be thinking about next?


Julie Gerg   

Wonderful question. When it comes down to what a leader should be thinking moving forward after all of those gifts are entered and imported and the data is accurate, it’s really important for leaders to be thinking about the stewardship cycle. So really driving home and understanding the point that the real opportunity begins after that initial transaction of giving your organization a gift and really seeing and understanding that there’s a lot of preparation that goes into a day of giving, but it’s also important to have A follow-up plan in place.


M Love-Tinker   

Why is it risky to treat GivingTuesday donors as one large group rather than as individuals entering different kinds of relationships with the organization?


Julie Gerg   

One of the real organizational weaknesses that can be presented when we treat our GivingTuesday donors as just a large group is the organization then does not have a consistent revenue coming into the organization on an annual basis. And that also makes it challenging for the organization to predict fundraising moving forward. And it also minimizes the impact that the gift has given when we are just treating those generous donors as one large group in comparison to individuals.
that have given to an organization that they care about.


M Love-Tinker   

In your experience, where does the post-campaign donor journey most commonly lose its momentum?


Julie Gerg   

In my experience, the most common point of where momentum is lost is after the gifts are all entered and there is a significant push from the organization to share the wonderful goals that were met, the number of donors really representing the success of the GivingTuesday. After that, there is this letdown and this feeling of success, which is accurate, but not losing momentum to push through to stewardship and focus on the next step for fundraisers is really where that momentum Gets lost.


M Love-Tinker   

What’s one of the early warning signs that an organization has focused more on processing gifts than beginning relationships?


Julie Gerg   

One of the signs that is certainly present is when an organization has these extremely strict deadlines on processing gifts and views the completion of GivingTuesday with that same metric. So when the gifts are entered as completion of the effort, which is really not honoring the relationship that is started with the transaction of Giving Day. And it’s also not allowing that relationship to develop.


M Love-Tinker   

So we’ve been hearing a lot about GivingTuesday in recent years. What makes GivingTuesday donors different from someone who comes in through an annual appeal or an event or maybe a major gift conversation or just a recurring giving program?


Julie Gerg   

Our GivingTuesday donors oftentimes engage with our organization in a different way than somebody who would give through a direct mail piece or tied to an event or even somebody who’s assigned A fundraiser within the organization. These individuals can be people who are indirectly tied to our organization through a common individual or a common group that care about the individual. So they’re oftentimes a little bit further, an arm’s length away from the organization than somebody who is already on a mailing list or a part of our organizational friends.


M Love-Tinker   

That’s some great info and that’s a great tip to remember, Julie. How can a nonprofit learn what motivated a donor without overwhelming that person with extra surveys or additional requests for information?


Julie Gerg   

Some of that information we already know, and that information is demonstrated in the gift that they give, whether they restrict the gift, how they came into the organization. On the backside, there’s a great way for us to be able to leverage our system that will give us some analytics on on the backside about how the person came into contact with the organization via the giving form. And it really does highlight the overall communication with the fundraising team and the other boots on the ground teams or individuals that are participating in GivingTuesday. So it might not always be a direct survey or ask to the donor, but there is data on the backside that we can leverage.


M Love-Tinker   

What post-campaign practices can unintentionally make a first-time donor feel like just another transaction?


Julie Gerg   

As much as I love a good receipt, a good receipt is also very transactional. It can make a donor feel as though they are just one of many, when really the intent is more focused on building that relationship. So one of those post-campaign practices, I would absolutely say a canned receipt is something that can really make a donor not feel like a friend to our organization.


M Love-Tinker   

I hear you, Julie. That can see can definitely stop the process right in its tracks there. When internal capacity is limited, which retention activity should nonprofits protect rather than postpone to make it feel more authentic and more of a relationship building?


Julie Gerg   

When we’re looking at a staff that may have limitations, it’s really important to focus in on those items that drive home that personal feel, that personal thank you, tying a gift directly back to impact on the institution and the organization.
is a great opportunity that should not be postponed. And there’s multiple ways that that could happen. That could be individualized thank you notes. That could be phone calls. It’s a great opportunity to segment your data and take a look at how we’re going to prioritize all of that. Those different opportunities where we could really impact retention for low cost. And thank you notes are a great way, but a very focused thank you note, not a general, a thank you note based on the gift and where it was restricted to.


M Love-Tinker   

So let us dive in a little bit deeper into that thank you process. Now that you mentioned that canned receipt, what should happen immediately after a GivingTuesday gift beyond sending that standard receipt?


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely, that standard receipt, we love it, but it’s really a great opportunity for us to send a handwritten thank you, a postcard that is directed at the restriction of the gift.
So if that is an organization that is raising funds for a food pantry, something that is very graphically designed to demonstrate your organization’s mission being carried out visually is very, very important. So there’s lots of opportunities where we can customize stewardship pieces at a low cost that are beyond that standard receipt. Of course, there is always the e-mail, thank you, the virtual, the newsletters, and the impact reports. All of those are great pieces to follow up that standard receipt.


M Love-Tinker   

Those are some great call outs, Julie. So essentially, we’re talking about the stewardship structure, like how are we structuring those follow-ups before we ask for another solicitation or another donation? What are some other ways that we can make that message feel meaningful to a donor we might not know a whole lot about initially?


Julie Gerg   

We can take the opportunity to tie that donor directly back to our organizational mission. Some of the activities of stewardship that that would look like is if there is board members who are willing to participate, this is a great opportunity to bring board members to the table and to thank these donors via phone calls. It’s a great opportunity for, if it’s a higher education or education institution, to utilize those students to hand sign thank you notes, kind of bridging the gap between the organization and the donor by filling in with real people who have been affected by your organization’s work.


M Love-Tinker   

So at what point can an organization introduce, let me start again.
At what point can an organization introduce another opportunity to engage, volunteer, advocate, attend an event, or maybe give again?


Julie Gerg   

This is a great question, M. This can look different for a lot of different organizations. It really does depend on the size and the structure. These opportunities to engage can be attendance at an event that is already existing, If there is a conference, a student conference that is being put on, that’s an opportunity for these individuals to bring them directly to your organization and tie them back to the good work that you do.
I do think that for GivingTuesday donors the opportunity to engage after stewardship is really important. That could be something as simple as after 60 days or after 90 days where they have received their standard receipt.
and they’ve received either a phone call or a written message or postcard that an opportunity to engage in a non-request for funds is an appropriate time frame.


M Love-Tinker   

Which GivingTuesday donor segments would you recommend reviewing first after all the gifts have been processed and acknowledged?


Julie Gerg   

Some of the really important segments to take a look at is to look at our most loyal donors to see if they are present as part of that and separating out that segment, since the majority of those segments might be individuals that already have existing relationships, and focusing in on those individuals that This may be their first gift or maybe it’s their second or third gift to GivingTuesday. There’s a real opportunity for us to pull that information out and take a look at our strategies and how we want to align that work. So recurring, would be an opportunity as well as lapsed. And if there’s somebody who’s attended events or engaged in the organization in another way, that would also be a great segment to look at and then align strategy.


M Love-Tinker   

So when we think about pulling that data out, you made a good point there about how we’re able to identify those folks in our system. So you and I happen to be working with Raiser’s Edge NXT, but really for any CRM that you’re using, what can be a way to use like maybe campaign, fund, appeal, to really use your CRM to pull those folks out and track them in your system so that you’re able to report on some retention data.


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely. Campaign Fund and PIL are a great.
Great question, M. Campaign funds and appeals are a great way to be able to track that engagement of GivingTuesday. When we are able to identify in any CRM that a person has given through GivingTuesday, It allows us to then use that information moving forward, and it allows us to segment that. Specifically in regards to campaign or funds, we can identify what our donors are truly passionate about. And that’s where the opportunity for stewardship, going back to stewardship, can present, it can help us recognize how exactly we can store our donors and maybe what a good strategy would be for engagement moving forward. And it really is any CRM that could be utilized in the same way. What’s really important is the consistency of tagging those donors as GivingTuesday donors.


M Love-Tinker   

So the goal is not segmentation for segmentation’s sake. It’s deciding who needs what type of follow-up and when it should happen and who actually owns it.


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely, very well said.


M Love-Tinker   

So what signals might suggest that a GivingTuesday donor may be receptive to recurring or monthly giving?


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely. This is a great question and this really addresses an organization’s long-term health with creating recurring gifts. Some of those signals that a GivingTuesday donor may be receptive to recurring gift is after we’ve segmented all of our data and we align some strategies with engagement, we will have additional data on are our GivingTuesday donors interested in engaging with us again after we’ve had the initial transaction of a gift. And what that can look like is open rates in emails, responses to phone calls, and as well as individual conversations with those that are.
volunteers at our organizations or that are currently staffed. So I think additional engagement is really the answer to that.


M Love-Tinker   

What should a team have in place before promoting a monthly giving program more broadly?


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely. Some of the important items to have in place before featuring a monthly giving program, some of those back end operational items, ensuring that you have a CRM that is able to process these gifts in an efficient way, that your staffing is structured to be able to respond to those gifts and process them quickly.
And on the donor side, it is really important to have information that is very clear and concise about the options that exist around monthly giving, a suggested ask amount that is appropriate for the donor, and flexibility to do that with minimal engagement with the organization, Or if there’s interest, additional engagement with the organization as well, offering the flexibility to meet the donor where they are and engage with them in the level that they are comfortable with.


M Love-Tinker   

Who should own GivingTuesday retention when fundraising, communications, gift processing, data management, and leadership all touch the donor experience?


Julie Gerg   

Oh, this is a team project by far. Everybody owns a certain portion of the GivingTuesday Success. When we think about the division of fundraising, we have our individuals that are those fundraisers that are out in front of our friends being the face of the organization. And then we have the individuals on the operation side that are in the back end. They are in the system. They are making sure that gifts are categorized and segmented correctly so that our other members of the team can then engage with them in an appropriate way and set strategy. And then we have our colleagues over in marketing, which really serve as a team to represent our organization on the public phase and the public side of things, sharing our good news, celebrating our successes, and building excitement. It’s really more of a team focus rather than one person. And in my experience, there is often a wonderful committee that has individuals from all of those pieces that are involved, from marketing to fundraisers to operations, somebody from stewardship so that they are aware of what is happening, really creating a cohesive team to then work on this very large and important piece of fundraising known as GivingTuesday.


M Love-Tinker   

So thinking about our CRMs and now some of the automations that have been built in to help small teams really execute on the donor journey, how would you suggest that small teams get started with using some of those automations maybe that the CRM has without losing that human relationship?


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely, some of those opportunities to use your CRM and automate some of those tasks, especially some of those early tasks, such as your standard receipts, there’s an opportunity to create workflows. And I’m using the term workflow specifically in regards to Raiser’s Edge, but that does not limit. There are other CRMs that have similar functionality that can automate those receipts and even some of the stewardship pieces that are more electronically focused based off some of the segmented data. So really an example of that would be for a donor that supported an athletic team within your education institution. That is data that exists within your system and creating automation to send out an e-mail for those individuals that gave to a specific fund at a specific time.
is a great example of being able to leverage your CRM in a way that is cost effective and staffing effective as well. And it doesn’t replace the human relationship, but it can add to it and bolster it.


M Love-Tinker   

Great point, Julie. So technology can help organize our work, but someone still needs to own the relationship in the next steps.


Julie Gerg   

Absolutely.


M Love-Tinker   

So Julie, if a nonprofit can make just one change this year to turn GivingTuesday donors into a more long-term, let me start over. Julie, if a nonprofit can make just one change this year to turn more GivingTuesday donors into long-term supporters, what should it do 1st and why?


Julie Gerg   

One of the very easy, low-hanging fruit items that an organization can do for GivingTuesday efforts to make sure that there is long-term success with supporters is to review the stewardship process to ensure that your thank you and gratitude of the initial transaction is not left the donor without the message that they are important to the organization, that we are grateful, and that their gift and support matters. And That is what will build the long-term success of GivingTuesday.


M Love-Tinker   

Thank you for joining us today for pocket operations, Julie.


Julie Gerg   

Thank you for the opportunity to be here, M. It’s been a joy to speak with you today.